California Lawmakers Slam EDD For Slow Payouts During COVID-19 Pandemic
SACRAMENTO (KPIX 5/AP) — California lawmakers accused the leader of the state's unemployment department of failing the public in a tense hearing Thursday that featured stories of people waiting weeks or months to receive their benefits after losing their jobs because of the pandemic.
More than 1.2 million claims, about a fifth of all applications, haven't been paid out, either because the applicants haven't taken the right steps or they are ineligible, said Sharon Hilliard, head of the Employment Development Department. It will take until September to process about 239,000 of those that are mostly ready to go but backlogged, she said.
"It's difficult to say this as someone who generally believes in government's ability to help, but EDD has been failing California," said Democratic Assemblyman David Chiu. "Our constituents are depleting their life savings, going into extreme debt, having trouble paying rent and putting food on the table."
The coronavirus pandemic caused millions of Californians to lose their jobs starting in March, and the state has paid out $55 billion, including federal dollars, across 9.3 million claims, Hilliard said. Applications skyrocketed by more than 3,000% from March to May compared to January and February, according to the agency.
The hearing came a day after Gov. Gavin Newsom announced a new "strike team" to improve the department. The agency has already spent millions contracting with outside vendors to improve its technology and provide more call center workers. By October, it plans to award a contract to completely redo its information technology system, a timeline lawmakers said wasn't nearly quick enough.
Chiu accused Hilliard of lying to the public about the unemployment data, another lawmaker said she had no faith in Hilliard or the agency, and members of the public called the state services "abominable" and suggested Hilliard be fired. Some who called in for public comment say they still haven't received any payment.
Hilliard defended the battered agency. She told lawmakers the agency has hired or redirected thousands of workers and plans to bring on more. She said common reasons payments are delayed is because the state needs more information to verify the applicant's identity or conduct a wage investigation.
"We remain laser focused on those claims that require additional action. Our staffers care deeply about the livelihood of our neighbors and our communities, which is why we continue to work round-the-clock in a committed effort to evolve our operations," Hilliard said.
A call center that can handle questions around specific claims has just 100 people working from 8 a.m. to 12 p.m., she said. The rest of the calls go through a line open seven days a week from 8 a.m. to 8 p.m. that can handle more basic calls. It takes on average four to six weeks for people to get a call back, Hilliard said.
The agency is working to merge the call centers and train more workers to handle complex calls to eliminate the need for call backs, Hilliard said. But she could not give a timeline for when that would happen despite repeated questions from Democratic Assemblywoman Cottie Petrie-Norris. Other lawmakers said it was unacceptable that so few workers are able to answer questions about claims over the phone.
"All of these timelines just seem totally out of step with the urgency of the moment that we are in," Petrie-Norris said.
Linda Margolin has been waiting for her benefit checks for six weeks.
"It's been more than frustrating, exasperating," said Margolin.
Margolin, who works as a travel counselor with Travel Advisors in Los Gatos, said she had her hours cut in May. She states she has submitted all the appropriate paperwork for her unemployment claim.
"They give you a bloody number to call, if you're on the work share, and you never can get through, you can start as early as 6 in the morning and be on the phone 12 hours."
Margolin said she's received only one benefit on June 19th.
"You cannot get a hold of anybody. And right now they probably owe me close to $5,000," she said.
Margolin is one hundreds of thousands -- and by some estimates well over a million Californians -- who have yet to be paid by the Employment Development Department. It says it's processing claims at historically high levels - up to three times greater than the peak seen during the great recession.
"My colleagues, my staff and I are at wits end," said Chiu. "We've attempted to offer suggestions, we have not seen them."
Even after hiring thousands of temporary employees, Hilliard committed to resolving a backlog of claims by the end of September.
She also admitted that the current wait for a call back from the department was up to six weeks.
Meanwhile just this week, the state saw more than 470,000 new claims.
"We're seeing a combination of a lot of the initial furloughs, now turning into layoffs," said former Director of the EDD Michael Bernick. "We're also seeing businesses that have tried to hang on, closing, and not only closing, but closing permanently."
"If I wasn't married, I don't know what I'd be doing. I'd be homeless," said Margolin.
The department is experiencing vastly more claims than at the height of the Great Recession, when the most claims processed in a single month was around 115,000. During a single week in late March, the state processed more than 1 million claims, said Chas Alamo, a policy analyst at the nonpartisan Legislative Analyst's Office. The federal government sets a goal of 87% of new claims being paid out within three weeks; California is currently paying out 62% of claims within that time frame, Alamo said. That's lower than the 50-state average.
Things could get even more complicated if Congress extends supplemental federal unemployment benefits, which gave people up to $600 in an additional weekly payments but just expired. The new program could require more complex calculations to determine payment amounts, and preparing the state's system to handle it could take 12 to 20 weeks, Hilliard said.
"I think that the level of outrage that you're hearing today would be nothing compared with the level of outrage if we were to tell the people of California it was going to take almost half a year to process their federal unemployment insurance supplement," said Republican Assemblyman Jay Obernolte.
The strike team Newsom created will have 45 days to produce a report on how to make the agency more digital and consumer friendly. The agency will also begin weekly outreach to applicants who need to send in more information or certify their claims, which much be done every two weeks.
Betty Yu contributed to this story.
© Copyright 2020 CBS Broadcasting Inc. All Rights Reserved. The Associated Press contributed to this report.
