Watch CBS News

Craig Crumbles

Craig Newmark, creator of Craigslist, has long had a much-used "Erotic Services" section on his website. He's finally agreed to dismantle that part of the site, under a torrent of pressure from across the country. But when I interviewed him, he was wasn't about to budge. And he wasn't about to apologize for it. First, he asked why I singled out Craigslist; his was not the only online site to offer such services, and newspapers, he pointed out, had done the same in their classified sections for years.
 
When I brought up the appalling fact that some of the prostitutes were underage, Newmark countered that Craigslist always cooperated with law enforcement investigating those cases.  I confirmed that was true, though only a step above the least he could do.
 
 As for those cases that may not have been detected by law enforcement? He was a big believer in his "user-monitored system." Newmark also contended that if Craigslist transitioned from a user-generated flagging mechanism to hiring people to vet and monitor the site, he'd open up the company to potential lawsuits. So far, no legal challenges have succeeded against the company, at least in that department.

However, now the "Erotic Services" section is closed and in its place: the title "Censored."

Up until now, it's seemed fairly clear that self-interest and protecting free speech rights were more important at Craigslist than the possibility of underage victims being pimped online and never flagged, discovered or rescued. So why the sudden change of heart?

When you have several state attorneys general breathing down your neck, I can't imagine it's a comfortable place to be. Whether or not they'd win, a lot of expensive lawsuits likely loomed on the horizon. Also the company's been fighting the issue for many years, and very publicly. That has to take a toll in the public relations department.

There is still debate about whether the shutdown is permanent. Some even speculate this will only chase the pimps to other outlets investigators now will have to hunt down. However, with the ease and exponentially increasing popularity of posting on Craigslist, this should at least slow down the sex business, if only temporarily. And with such a high-profile company, other online sites will likely take notice - and maybe think twice about helping the promotion of the sex trade.

As a journalist, the concept of free speech is just as sacred to me as it might be to you. But speech isn't "free" if victimized and brutalized kids have to pay for it.

Here's a snippet of that conversation:

Craig: "There are prostitution ads on our site, and people who care flag them, and they do get removed; but the message from our community overwhelmingly is a live and let live message. People's priorities are elsewhere."

He added: "We wanted to offer legitimate erotic services to people who want them to give people a break."

View CBS News In
CBS News App Open
Chrome Safari Continue
Be the first to know
Get browser notifications for breaking news, live events, and exclusive reporting.