NYC Mayor Mamdani signs bill banning horse carriage industry into law
New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani signed the horse carriage ban into law Thursday as workers vow to legally challenge it.
The mayor signed Romanch's Law at 9:30 a.m. at City Hall. In October, the City Council passed the bill, which sets a June 2028 deadline to phase out horse carriages.
Horse-drawn carriages have been a fixture in Central Park for more than 160 years.
"Our city has changed. Now it is time for our laws to change too," Mamdani said.
The legislation is named after 18-year-old Romanch Mahajan, a tourist from India who was killed after a horse became startled and threw him from a carriage in Central Park.
"This is a truly historic day for New York City, nearly two decades after the Council first considered ending the horse-drawn carriage industry," said Speaker Julie Menin. "Today, I'm thinking of Romanch Mahajan, who should still be with us and whose tragic, untimely death reminds us why this legislation was so urgently needed."
There was jubilation at City Hall as Mamdani signed the legislation that will mean the death knell for the horse carriage industry in New York.
"This is a new day for our city. One that will make the crown jewel of Manhattan's parks safer, while also recognizing the lasting legacy and contributions the horse carriage industry has made in our city," Mamdani said.
"One thing became abundantly clear," Menin said. "Unless we act, and unless we act with urgency, unless we do something to prevent another fatality from happening in our great Central Park, this would continue."
Efforts to ban the industry have gone on for decades. Bill de Blasio made it a key plank in his 2013 campaign for mayor.
"I think the tragedy brought it home to a lot of New Yorkers very emotionally, very humanly," de Blasio said.
But will it survive a court challenge from those who oppose it?
Immediately after the bill was signed, the Transport Workers Union filed a lawsuit against the city. Union leaders, attorneys and carriage workers gathered outside the federal courthouse in Manhattan at noon to outline their legal challenge, claiming the ban is unconstitutional.
"There are alternatives to putting 300 people out of work. There are alternatives to destroying $20 million worth of medallions. There are alternatives the city has not considered," attorney Arthur Schwartz said.
Christine Hansen is a driver who owns five horses.
"This is a national disgrace today about what is happening to the Central Park horse carriages," she said.
"Let me tell you, I am so tired of watching my fellow carriage drivers and my friends be bullied, harassed and accused of horrible things when they are the most gentle and good-spirited and loving people that I have met in this city. Their priority is the care of their horses, and they've devoted their lives to working alongside them," said carriage driver Danielle Slott.
City Councilmember Christopher Marte, who sponsored the bill, pledged the drivers will be taken care of.
"We look forward to working with the TWU and all the independent contractors to make sure they get a fair compensation and they get the jobs that they want," Marte said.
Mamdani said the city will work with the drivers to develop a compensation plan and to help them find other work. He also ordered a feasibility study to see if electric carriages and pedal-assist bicycles can replace the horses.