Six Baltimore Police Officers Charged In Homicide Of Freddie Gray
BALTIMORE (CBSNewYork/AP) -- Saying "no one is above the law,'' Baltimore's top prosecutor announced charges Friday against six officers in the arrest of a black man whose neck was broken in police custody, a decision that comes amid outrage around the country over police brutality against African-Americans.
State's Attorney Marilyn Mosby declared that Freddie Gray's death was a homicide, his arrest was illegal, and his treatment amounted to murder and manslaughter. She detailed what happened to Gray during his arrest and his nearly 45-minute ride in a police wagon, contradicting what police have said on some points and shedding far more light on what happened during his fatal journey.
Gray carried a legal pocket knife, she said, not the illegal switchblade that an officer described under penalty of perjury. And officers repeatedly denied Gray's requests for medical attention, even when he said he couldn't breathe. At one point, he was shackled at the legs, handcuffed behind his back, and put back into the wagon on his stomach.
Continuing Coverage: CBS Baltimore
At another stop, an officer "spoke to the back of Mr. Gray's head,'' and even though he was unresponsive, made "no effort to look or assess or determine his condition,'' Mosby said.
Mosby is the youngest prosecutor in a major U.S. city. As CBS2's Dick Brennan reported, she comes from five generations of police officers.
"The findings of our comprehensive, thorough and independent investigation, coupled with the medical examiner's determination that Mr. Gray's death was a homicide,'' Mosby said, "has led us to believe that we have probable cause to file criminal charges.''
PHOTOS: NYC Rally, March In Solidarity With Baltimore Protests
Onlookers cheered and expressed amazement over Mosby's announcement. Few expected such quick action. The city, which saw looting and businesses and cars burned on Monday, remains under a nighttime curfew, with National Guard troops and police out in full force and huge protests expected Friday and Saturday. More than 200 people have been arrested and nearly 100 officers injured in the unrest following Gray's funeral.
Cheers and shouts of "Justice!'' erupted as Mosby announced the charges, less than a day after receiving the results of an internal police investigation and the autopsy report.
"Mr. Gray suffered a severe and critical neck injury as a result of being handcuffed, shackled by his feet and unrestrained inside of the BPD wagon,'' she said.
The stiffest charge -- second-degree "depraved heart'' murder -- was filed against driver of the police van. The other five were charged with crimes including manslaughter, assault, false imprisonment and misconduct in office.
Fraternal Order of Police local president Gene Ryan told Mosby in a letter before the charges were announced Friday that none of the six suspended officers were responsible for Gray's death.
A lawyer for some of the officers accused Mosby of a rush to judgment that raises grave concerns about the integrity of the prosecution.
"The officers did nothing wrong,'' Attorney Michael Davey insisted Friday afternoon. "These injuries did not occur as a result of any action or inaction on the part of these officers.''
President Barack Obama said he doesn't comment on the legal process, but it's "absolutely vital that the truth comes out.''
"I can tell you that justice needs to be served,'' Obama said. "Those individuals who are charged obviously are also entitled to due process and rule of law.''
Mosby said Gray was assaulted by Garrett E. Miller, Officer William G. Porter, Officer Edward M. Nero, Lt. Brian W. Rice and Sgt. Alicia D. White. Each faces up to 10 years if convicted of second-degree assault. The van driver, Officer Caesar R. Goodson Jr., faces up to 30 years on the murder charge, and 10 years each for involuntary manslaughter, assault and "manslaughter by vehicle.''
All of the officers also face a charge of misconduct in office.
The charges with the respective maximum penalties are as follows:
Officer Caesar R. Goodson, Jr.:
1) Second degree depraved heart murder (30 yrs.)
2) Manslaughter (involuntary) (10 yrs.)
3) Assault/second degree (10 yrs.)
4) Manslaughter by vehicle (gross negligence) (10 yrs.)
5) Manslaughter by vehicle (criminal negligence) (3 yrs.)
6) Misconduct in office (8th Amendment*)
Officer William G. Porter:
1) Manslaughter (involuntary) (10 yrs.)
2) Assault/second degree (10 yrs.)
3) Misconduct in office (8th Amendment*)
Lt. Brian W. Rice:
1) Manslaughter (involuntary) (10 yrs.)
2) Assault/second degree (10 yrs.)
3) Assault/second degree (10 yrs.)
4) Misconduct in office (8th Amendment*)
5) Misconduct in office (8th Amendment*)
6) False imprisonment (8th Amendment*)
Officer Edward M. Nero:
1) Assault/second degree (10 yrs.)
2) Assault/second degree (10 yrs.)
3) Misconduct in office (8th Amendment*)
4) Misconduct in office (8th Amendment*)
5) False imprisonment (8th Amendment*)
Officer Garrett E. Miller:
1) Assault/second degree (10 yrs.)
2) Assault/second degree (10 yrs.)
3) Misconduct in office (8th Amendment*)
4) Misconduct in office (8th Amendment*)
5) False imprisonment (8th Amendment*)
Sgt. Alicia D. White:
1) Manslaughter (involuntary) (10 yrs.)
2) Assault/second degree (10 yrs.)
3) Misconduct in office (8th Amendment*)
Mayor Stephanie Rawlings-Blake said these charges should lead to a change in culture for the police.
"To those of you who wish to engage in brutality, misconduct, racism and corruption, let me be clear: There is no place in the Baltimore City Police Department for you,'' she said.
Mosby said she comes from five generations of police officers, that she respects and honors how police serve the people, and that this case should in no way damage the relationship between police and prosecutors in Baltimore.
She swiftly rejected a request from the Baltimore police officers union asking her to appoint a special independent prosecutor because of her ties to attorney Billy Murphy, who is representing Gray's family. Murphy was among Mosby's biggest campaign contributors last year, donating the maximum individual amount allowed, $4,000, in June. Murphy also served on Mosby's transition team after the election.
At the corner of Pennsylvania and North avenues, where the worst of the rioting took place on Monday, drivers honked their horns. When buses stopped in front of the subway station, people spilled out cheering as the doors opened.
There was no large gathering at the intersection immediately after the announcement, though: Nearly 100 police in riot gear were deployed, and for the moment, they had nothing to do.
Ciara Ford, of Baltimore, expressed surprise at the decision to prosecute.
"I'm ecstatic,'' she said. "I hope this can restore some peace.''
"It makes you cry,'' said her friend, Stephanie Owens of Columbia.
They both hoped the officers would be convicted. And both believed that the protests in the city made a difference in ensuring that authorities took the case seriously.
"If we had kept quiet, I don't think they would have prosecuted,'' Ford said.
Community activist Ted Sutton surveyed the joyous scene with amazement. "You don't see people chanting. What you see is people celebrating,'' Sutton said.
The charges, and Mosby's detailed explanation of what happened, are a first step toward transparency, he said.
"She took the time to critique the evidence,'' Sutton said, noting that the officers faced different charges specific to their actual alleged misconduct. "To have each person charged with what they actually did . to have it come out this quick -- this is something else.''
Councilwoman Helen Holton said the decision to bring charges was a "defining moment'' and noted other injustices against blacks, from Emmett Till, a teenager killed after flirting with a white woman in Mississippi in 1955, to Rodney King, who was beaten by Los Angeles police in 1991 to Walter Scott, who was fatally shot running away from an officer in South Carolina earlier this year.
"My God, how many more black men must die before we say enough? Hopefully, Freddie Gray will be the last. If not, it is my fervent prayer that Baltimore city will lead the nation to say, 'We will take down those who violate the rights of citizens, any citizens,''' she said. "I'm psyched today! I'm like, `Whoo!' My feet are not even touching the ground.''
(TM and © Copyright 2015 CBS Radio Inc. and its relevant subsidiaries. CBS RADIO and EYE Logo TM and Copyright 2015 CBS Broadcasting Inc. Used under license. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. The Associated Press contributed to this report.)
