Man convicted of murder in death of Laken Riley, Georgia nursing student killed on jogging trail
A judge has convicted the man on trial for the killing of Laken Riley, a nursing student in Georgia whose death in February shook the college town where she studied, as well as the country.
Jose Ibarra, 26, was found guilty Wednesday morning of murder and other charges related to Riley's death. He was sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole.
Ibarra, an undocumented Venezuelan immigrant, entered the United States illegally in 2022, officials said, but he was allowed to remain in the country to pursue his immigration case. His status helped bring the national debate over border laws to a boiling point earlier this year, as prominent Republicans, including President-elect Donald Trump, blamed President Biden's policies for Riley's death.
The verdict handed down by Athens-Clarke County Superior Court Judge H. Patrick Haggard marked the end of four days of emotional hearings that began last week. Ibarra waived his right to a jury trial after pleading not guilty to a 10-count indictment brought against him in the wake of Riley's killing, which meant the case would be heard and decided solely by the judge. He also declined to testify during the trial.
The state had charged Ibarra with one count of malice murder, three counts of felony murder and one count each of kidnapping, aggravated assault, aggravated battery, hindering an emergency telephone call, tampering with evidence, and being a "peeping Tom." That final charge stemmed from prosecutors' allegation that Ibarra peered into the window of an apartment in a university residential building on the day Riley was murdered. Prosecutors said he was "hunting for females on the University of Georgia's campus" when he encountered Riley.
Ibarra was found guilty on all 10 counts. Audible wails were heard in the courtroom when Haggard announced the verdict, citing a portion of the prosecution's closing argument that emphasized the evidence against Ibarra was "overwhelming and powerful." The defendant, receiving the news in Spanish through a translator, maintained the stoicism he displayed in court throughout the trial.
Haggard heard impact statements from Riley's loved ones after reading the verdict. Her parents, sister, roommates and friends spoke through tears while they described Riley as a cheerful, ambitious and generous young person who valued her faith and prioritized helping others. Many called Ibarra a monster and the crime an act of evil, and Riley's classmates said separately they now fear for their safety at school. The prosecution also shared excruciating video of the moment police told Riley's family she was dead.
Everyone who gave statements pressed the judge to impose the maximum sentence. Prosecutors did not seek the death penalty in this case.
"There is no end to the pain, suffering and loss that we have experienced or will continue to endure," said Riley's mother, Allyson Phillips, in her remarks. "This sick, twisted and evil coward showed no regard for Laken or human life. We are asking the same be done to him."
Riley was found dead on Feb. 22 in a wooded part of the University of Georgia campus in Athens, where she was enrolled in the Augusta University College of Nursing. The 22-year-old had gone for a run that morning through the school's intramural fields, which was routine for her, and a concerned friend called University of Georgia police at around noon once Riley failed to return. She often talked to her mother on the phone while out running in the mornings, so when Riley's friends and family did not hear from her, they worried something was wrong.
Phillips called and texted her daughter several times after missing an initial call from Riley just after 9 a.m., according to logs and messages pulled from the student's phone and shown in court Tuesday, as the state's case wound down. Phillips and other family members continued to reach out to Riley for several hours when she did not reply.
Phillips cried at the Tuesday hearing as her text messages were read aloud on the stand by Georgia Police Sgt. Sophie Raboud, one of the lead investigators in Riley's case. In one of her final messages to Riley at 11:47 a.m., her mother wrote, "You're making me nervous not answering while you're out running. Are you OK?"
Riley's mother, along with family and friends in attendance, became emotional at a different point in Raboud's testimony where she answered questions about the video being played of Riley running the morning of her death.
Ibarra was arrested the following day and booked without bond in the Athens-Clarke County Jail. Police have said Riley's killing appeared to be a random attack. But the indictment returned by a Georgia grand jury in May detailed a gruesome confrontation in which Ibarra allegedly asphyxiated the student, hit her over the head with a rock to the point of disfiguring her skull, and pulled up her clothing, intending to rape her.
In court, attorneys for the state also described a disturbing scene. Prosecutor Sheila Ross said Friday that Ibarra killed Riley violently after a prolonged struggle.
"When Laken Riley refused to be his rape victim, he bashed her skull in with a rock repeatedly," Ross told the judge. She said evidence — including surveillance footage, traces of Ibarra's DNA under Riley's fingernails, and his thumbprint left behind on her phone screen — would show the student "fought for her life, for her dignity" over almost 20 minutes.
Data from Riley's watch indicated she stopped suddenly in the middle of her run at around 9:10 a.m. the day she died and called 911 about a minute later. The watch showed Riley's heart was still beating until 9:28 a.m., Ross said.
Ibarra's defense attorney, Dustin Kirby, had argued the prosecution's evidence against his client was circumstantial and did not prove his guilt. Ibarra has appeared in court with shackles around his ankles and headphones to follow a translation of the trial proceedings in Spanish.
"The evidence in this case is very good that Laken Riley was murdered," Kirby said. Still, the defense has tried to challenge the strength of the prosecution's evidence, saying even the DNA sample may not completely rule out other suspects. Ibarra's legal team raised questions, for example, about whether one of his brothers could have committed the crime. The defendant's brother Diego Ibarra worked a shift at the University of Georgia's dining hall on the day of the murder.
Witness testimony for the prosecution continued into Monday, when an FBI Special Agent James Burnie told the court that electronic location data seemed to place Riley and Ibarra in the same wooded area at the time of her death. GPS coordinates from Riley's cellphone and smartwatch confirmed her precise location in the area where officers found her body, and pings between Ibarra's phone and cell towers suggested he was likely in the woods, too, Burnie said.
Prosecutors during that hearing also played a recording for the court of a May phone call between Ibarra's wife, Layling Franco, and Ibarra while he was in jail. On the call, Ibarra told Franco he had been looking for work at the University of Georgia, and his wife urged him multiple times to tell her the truth about what happened to Riley, FBI specialist Abeisis Ramirez said during his testimony. The recording of their conversation was translated from Spanish for the court.
The jail call was not admitted into evidence in Ibarra's trial and could not be considered in the case, Judge Haggard announced Tuesday morning.
"After hearing the translations I do find that it was more than contextual, and therefore violates the confrontation clause of the 6th Amendment," the judge said. The clause protects the rights of an individual accused of a crime to confront witnesses.
