How to Manage Employees in Remote Locations
Thanks to technology and globalization, more and more business
teams are working together across state lines and international borders. Many corporations
employ "dispersed teams," where a manager in New York may communicate daily with colleagues in Boston, Los Angeles, and Singapore.
But even with an array of new Web-based collaboration tools at their disposal, most managers find handling remote teams extremely challenging. In order to get the best out of your far-flung employees, you need to establish a clear communication routine, take extra steps to build trust, and review processes often to make sure they're working for everyone. Whether your employees are in other company offices, working from home, or a little bit of both, these tips will help keep your team running smoothly.
Build a Strong Team, Starting with You
Goal: Make sure you’re up for the task of
managing remotely.
Managers who run dispersed teams successfully share several
traits. They work a lot, they travel — some more than half the time —
and they thrive on their work and the culture they’ve created. “Remote
managers need more energy, because a lot of what you have to do is transfer
that energy to your team,” says Juliana Slye, who manages remote
employees as director of the government division at software maker Autodesk,
based in San Rafael, California. The successful remote manager has the
following traits:
Passion. A remote set-up won’t work unless your
employees are motivated and running in sync — collaborating, asking
each other for help, sharing ideas. That energy has to start with you. You don’t
need to start each day smiling from ear to ear, but if you’re annoyed
every time an IM breaks your train of thought or you’re not good
about remembering to check in with people, running remote teams probably isn’t
for you.
Availability. Good remote communication requires extra
effort. You need to go out of your way to address issues that would come up
naturally and spontaneously if you all worked in one place. When your staff is
spread across a number of time zones, they need to feel comfortable calling you
at odd hours — even if it’s dinner hour. Beyond the
guidance or answers you can provide, which allows them to move forward with
their work, your availability shows support, which helps strengthen your
relationships with everyone. That said, establish reasonable guidelines about
when to call.
Patience. A two-hour dinner with an employee across the country
may take up two days with travel time. And it may take two hours instead of 10
minutes to schedule a conference call. The lesson here? Budget extra time for
common group tasks. This doesn’t necessarily hurt productivity. For
instance, conference calls are usually shorter and more to the point than a
meeting in person, where members of the group are bound to do more small talk.
Reliability. By doing what you say you’ll do —
whether it’s helping solve a problem or sending a new laptop —
you foster trust. Your reliability shows respect for what your workers are
doing. Without that, they’ll quit asking for help, and you’ll
fall out of the loop. “Trust is particularly important in distance
relationships,” says management consultant Debra Dinnocenzo, author of
“How to Lead from a Distance.” “You build trust
through actions that demonstrate reliability, integrity, and familiarity.”
Checklist
Five Ways to Build Trust
Asked how he makes sure his team is keeping him in the loop,
remote manager Dan Belmont, chief marketing officer of the Marketing Arm,
a Dallas-based agency that promotes sports and entertainment events, says he
makes himself part of their “network” by working beside them.
“If you’re in the trenches doing the work,” he
says, “you’re not just perceived as someone who is managing
people and processes.” Belmont makes himself available to brainstorm or
solve problems and typically spends an hour a week on the phone with each of
his 14 employees.
Here are more ways to build trust:
- Be available. Don’t let employee calls go to
voicemail. When you absolutely can’t be reached, reply ASAP. - Beware of using sarcasm and teasing in distance
interactions, like email and conference calls, where signals can easily
get crossed. - Handle sensitive issues with discretion. One team member
might tell Belmont that another is having a bad day. He’ll
immediately call the person having the bad day, without exposing the colleague
who told him. - Communicate in a variety of ways (email, phone, in person,
etc) and often. - Visit employees on their turf. It shows respect for their
time and interest in their life outside the job.
Gather the Right People
Goal: Build a team that can work well at a distance.
A dispersed team depends on people who can be productive without
a boss roaming the hallways or a trusted co-worker sitting nearby. Team members
should be motivated, disciplined, and flexible with their time, allowing them to
connect with clients or co-workers in different time zones. “People
who like to quit at 5 p.m. aren’t the people who work well remotely,”
says Michelle LaBrosse, CEO of Cheetah Learning, a project-management
training company based in Carson City, Nevada. They also need to communicate
clearly in writing (since e-mail and instant messaging are the new standard for
daily communication) and should be willing to suggest ideas, ask for and offer
help, make decisions, and collaborate.
Below are a few suggestions for setting up a remote work arrangement.
For more tips, see
href="http://www.bnet.com/2403-13068_23-166424.html">Hiring
and Inspiring a Dispersed Team.
Match people to the work. Extroverts and idea people tend
to like tasks that require frequent and ongoing communication. Make sure they’re
in an office with teammates they can collaborate with. Introverts and people
confident making decisions can work more easily at home or on solo projects.
Match work to the time zone. If some employees are working
while others sleep, try to avoid assigning work that leaves team members
perpetually in the hurry-up-and-wait cycle, as their counterparts half a world
away complete their part of a project.
Assign backups. For the most critical tasks, make sure
you or someone else in your group can fill in on a moment’s notice,
like when someone is ill or quits. (And make sure you can access a remote
worker’s files and contacts from afar.)
Sign an agreement. Specify when and how much a person may
need to work, times they need to be available, performance objectives, and
frequency of in-person meetings. This codifies expectations and provides
something tangible for your employee to refer back to.
Assess. At least a few times a year, ask what’s
working and what’s not, then make changes if necessary. Withdrawal is
a common sign of a problem. Even if a person is meeting deadlines and producing
quality work, they may be unhappy if you hear from them less and less.
Big Idea
Connecting the Dots
After studying dozens of virtual teams, including groups at BP,
Nokia, and Ogilvy & Mather, researchers at the London Business School
recommend the following:
Recruit volunteers. Look within the company for
volunteers to lead a new committee or research a new opportunity, rather than
just assigning such tasks. “Virtual teams appear to thrive when they include volunteers with valuable skills —
people whose proof of commitment is their willingness to join the team on their
own,” writes Lynda Gratton, a professor of management with the school,
in a 2007 Wall Street Journal article.
Add “boundary spanners” to each virtual team. “Boundary spanners are
people who, as a result of their personality, skills, or work history, have
lots of connections to useful people outside the team,” Gratton
writes. They play a strong networking role, keeping the team and its
accomplishments visible within the company. Nokia cultivates boundary spanners
by introducing each new hire to at least 10 people both inside and outside their
department. Read the full article at
href="http://online.wsj.com/public/article_print/SB118165895540732559.html">The
Wall Street Journal Online.
Put Technology to Work
Goal: Find tools that fit both the job and the people who
use them.
When it comes to technology, there’s only one clear-cut
prescriptive: Let the work dictate the tool. Don’t invest in the
latest whiz-bang technology and then try to figure out how it will be
useful. Phone, email, instant messaging, a company intranet, and a broadband
connection are a good starting point. You can add collaboration software later
and unify your communications if the investment seems worthwhile. For the
low-down on new and popular business technology, see
href="http://www.bnet.com/2403-13059_23-166425.html">Ten Tools for Remote Teams. Below are a few
guidelines for making the most of your existing equipment:
Be tech savvy. Beyond the platforms and software your
company uses, you need to continually research the newest tools for the sake of
efficiency and collaboration — often to keep up with what your
savvier team members are already using. Maybe they use IM all day long and you
like the phone. Yes, you call the shots, but ask yourself what will make your people
most productive and satisfied. Maybe it’s time you started using IM,
too. Ask your peers what they like and what they don’t. You can go
online to test drive some tools, like Microsoft’s SharePoint
collaboration software.
Get creative with basic technology. Louisville,
Kentucky-based PR firm Corecubed records conference-call brainstorming sessions
so that participants can truly free-flow their thoughts. “No one’s
taking notes, everyone’s being creative, so it’s great to
have that follow-up,” says Corecubed managing director Merrily Orsini.
She paid $150 at Radio Shack for a digital voice recorder that connects to her
handset. Her admin downloads the recordings to Corecubed’s intranet
site, then transcribes them. Employees refer back to the sessions to refresh their
memories on a topic or check who’s responsible for which tasks.
Set up support systems. Know who will take responsibility
for technical problems on the remote end. This applies particularly to
home-based employees and contractors. At Alpine Access, a Denver-based virtual
call center, technical help has been streamlined for its home-based agents. “We
have a technical support desk that’s able to fix 90 to 95 percent of
computer problems over the Internet,” says CEO Chris Carrington. For
problems that can’t be fixed virtually, Alpine will FedEx a new
thin-client computer to the agent’s home. Carrington says he’d
rather retain the best workers than require, as some companies do, that their
remote workers live within a short drive of company headquarters.
For Example
Craft Your Own Tool
The Marketing Arm, a marketing agency focusing on sports,
entertainment, and promotions, launched an internal website, IdeaLink, to tap the
creativity of its more than 1,100 workers around the world. Anyone from
accountants to administrative assistants can log on to read a creative brief
for a campaign and then chime in with ideas. “Some of the quietest
people here — who would never come to a creative meeting — are
first to respond,” says creative manager Stu Hill. To encourage
participation, the company rewards the strongest ideas with cash and other
prizes, like roundtrip airline tickets. The IdeaLink site also fosters
community through an idea blog and an employee directory, complete with
pictures, hobbies, and interests.
Master the Art of Communication
Goal: Keep you and your employees connected in a
meaningful way.
Lack of communication and the frequency of misinterpretation are
perpetual sore subjects in most workplaces. Add in distance and the challenges
are only amplified. Communicating well encompasses much more than the tools you
use. It’s about how often you use them, what you say, and how you say
it. Here’s how to be deliberate in communicating with the troops.
Start with Standard Ops
Decide what five or so communications guidelines are most
important for your type of work, drive those home, and let the little stuff go.
For example, most managers want to hear about a sensitive or complex issue over
the phone, instead of email, to avoid misunderstandings.
Doc Parghi, senior vice president of sales at software-testing
firm App Labs, works in the company’s Philadelphia headquarters and
has eight direct reports in Utah, India, and the United Kingdom. “In
email, one of the things we’ve never
tolerated is the one-line response,” he says. Company guidelines dictate
that in each email message, the subject line needs to specify the topic and the
primary recipients need to be addressed in the greeting, so that people who are
CC’ed know that they do not need to take any action.
Establish a Routine
It may feel unnatural or overly prescribed, but meeting agendas
and weekly update emails can save you lots of grief when it comes to
communicating with remote teams. Slye of Autodesk says that when one employee admitted
she found their weekly one-on-one phone meetings confusing, the two created a
structure to help their conversations stay on topic. They now spend a half hour
on tactical items, like roles and responsibilities, deadlines, or problems with
a current marketing effort. “Then we close our laptops and go into
brainstorming mode,” Slye says. “In an office environment,
you see someone’s face switching from something general to specific.
There are cues we take from body language.” That’s not the
case when all you have is a voice. Slye and her employee now divide any
correspondence that way, including email and face-to-face meetings.
Allow for Personal Preferences
When people work from afar, the greatest risk you run is that
they won’t reach out to you enough, leaving you out of the loop. As
the manager, you need to encourage them to communicate in the way that’s
most effective and comfortable for them. For example, if you want details from
an employee who’s a slow typist, call her. By contrast, you may use
email more often with a shy employee who would rather type than talk.
Know Your Limits
Workplace consultant Ben Dattner will tell you that most
dispersed teams are not involved in the kind of work that requires constant
collaboration. Creative teams that spend the day brainstorming and building on
each other’s ideas, for example, typically still work inside the same
four walls. Understand what kind of tasks can be done remotely, and what is
still best accomplished by a localized team. For example, ideas can be
generated on a chat room or other collaboration tool, but refining or improving
upon them may require the kind of give and take that only happens in a live
meeting.
Hot Tip
Handling Hard Days
“Remote employees are very conscious of managing
your perception of them,” Slye says. “They don’t
bring a problem to you until it has really escalated, because they don’t
want to burden you or take up your time.” Without clues like a heavy
sigh or a frustrated look on someone’s face, it’s hard to
know when workers need support. “You have to be disciplined as a
manager to get out of the email thread,” Slye says. “You have
to pick up the phone.”
When she checks in with employees each week, Slye stays away
from vague questions, like ‘How’s it going?’ and
simply assumes that there are always some problems. “I ask, ‘What
kind of challenges are you having?’” she says. “Nine
times out of 10 that’s going to kick up something.” Rather
than try to resolve the issue herself, she keeps employees focused on their own
capacity to solve problems, asking, “What would you like to see happen
in a perfect world? Are any of those things achievable? How could you achieve
them? What could you do today?”
Build a Sense of “We”
Goal: Establish strong relationships to fuel
motivation, collaboration, and productivity.
Recent research from the Gallup Organization’s Tom
Rath shows that people with strong friendships at work are more motivated,
loyal, collaborative, and productive. In a typical office, those relationships
form naturally. Across remote locations, you need to foster not just your
connection to your employees, but their connections to each other.
Face Time
To build relationships, there’s no substitute for meeting
face to face. In person, your employees are more likely to tell you about what’s
not working. You’ll better understand their work style, too —
how they make decisions and which types of tasks they’re best suited
for. There’s no set equation for how often to meet, but twice a year
is a good rule of thumb. Many remote managers schedule one-on-ones around
hiring and performance reviews. Team meetings should be scheduled around
planning and decision-making. LaBrosse of Cheetah Learning says her teams meet
in person to kick off a project and again when the project is finished.
Teambuilding gets mixed reviews in the corporate world, but it
takes on greater meaning for people who rarely see one another. Each year the
Corecubed staff converges at Orsini’s home in Louisville, Kentucky, for Derby weekend. “People stay at each other’s
houses, so they get to know them better,” she says. “You see
pictures of the kids and you get to meet the dog. It reinforces our need to
make certain that each of us succeeds.” If you plan a
team gathering, make the time count. Find something everyone will appreciate, schedule
it at a time that won’t impact people getting their work done, and if
someone doesn’t want to participate in social events, don’t
force it.
Rewards and Recognition
The pats on the back that happen informally around the office don’t
come as easily in the virtual world. Remote colleagues need to make greater
effort to recognize each other’s accomplishments, LaBrosse says. Her
employees at Cheetah Learning can hand out 2,000 “Cheetah Points”
to each other every month. When one co-worker helps another solve a difficult
problem, the first may give the second 200 points. At the end of the month,
LaBrosse gives away $500, $300, and $200 worth of gift certificates to the
three people with the most points. “People are happier,” she
says. “We have virtually no turnover.”
Turnover is also low for Alpine Access, which outsources
call-center services using a workforce of entirely home-based agents. A ticker
runs at the bottom of every agent’s computer screen, carrying
messages specific to their team or the client they serve, like J. Crew or 1-800-Flowers.
Team supervisors listen in on calls and immediately transmit messages such as, “Tina
just had a huge sale!” across the network. Then congratulations pile
in from other agents, says Carrington. “You transfer that excitement
to the other agents,” he says. “That can be an immediate
energy pick-me-up. People think. ‘I can do that, too.’”
Nitty Gritty
Connecting Through Technology
The tools your employees use to work remotely can also build
rapport. Here are a few ways that technology can foster virtual community.
1. Start an email newsletter. Profile articles can put a
face on co-workers, especially when they give kudos for work- or
community-related accomplishments.
2. Set up a chat capability on your website and create
internal forums based on what your team wants, be it topics affiliated with
work or socializing. Alpine Access holds a “virtual happy hour”
every Thursday afternoon, off the clock. Employees share everything from
weekend plans to recipes.
3. Host a blogging network. At Sun Microsystems, CEO
Jonathan Schwartz blogs extensively several times a month. Employees pose
questions and he answers them, making him highly visible and accessible.
4. Use PowerPoint for introductions. Three or four times a
year, Slye’s Autodesk team holds a web conference where each employee
gives a personal PowerPoint presentation, including what they’re
responsible for, what they really do, what motivates them, what bugs them,
their personal interests, and their goals. “The questions are designed
to be intimate,” she says. “We’re engineering entry
points for personal conversation.”
Manage by Results
Goal: Focus on the quality of your employees’
work, not their style of doing it.
The nuances of how people work, and when, become more pronounced
when you’re remote, but they’re not a good basis for
performance evaluation. Forget points of style — how long it takes an
employee to reply to emails, for example — and focus on the results:
both tangible and intangible. Tangible results might include the proposal an
employee submits for next quarter’s operating plan and whether it’s
comprehensive, on target, and on time. The intangibles are just as important:
whether she collaborates well, makes decisions on her own, delivers what she
promises, anticipates problems before they happen, generates ideas,
communicates clearly, takes responsibility for her work, and goes beyond the
call of duty, say to help a new co-worker get up to speed on a client.
Set goals and expectations. Set and revisit expectations
and goals, and put them in writing. Lay out requirements for the job and the
relative importance to you and the company of meeting deadlines versus
producing quality work, or giving a client what he wants versus the cost to
your organization of giving it to him.
Take notes. Jot quick anecdotes about each employee’s
performance, positive and negative, every few weeks. Your notes become a
starting point for the next performance review.
Require reports. When work has a lot of variables
(clients, contact with the media, etc.), reports give you a glimpse of how
workers are spending their time. Orsini of Corecubed doesn’t
expect people to be at their desks 9 to 5, but since her company bills clients
for time, she asks employees to track their hours and estimate percentages of
time spent on types of tasks.
Ask detailed questions. The more you talk to everyone, the better
sense you’ll get for whether each person on the team is playing the
role they need to. Don’t ask Eric if Andrea is doing her job well.
That puts him on the spot. Ask specific questions about the project they’re
both working on — which tasks he and she are working on this week, and
what challenges they’re having — to get clues about her
role.
Danger! Danger! Danger!
Avoiding Burnout
While a results approach to managing frees workers from a
set shift, some forget to look at the clock entirely, and that can lead to
burnout. For remote managers, the trick is recognizing that an employee is
losing steam before the person quits or drop the ball on a project. “Burnout
is usually exhibited by people not completing deliverables because they have
too many other things on their plate,” LaBrosse says. “The
more emails that are going out, the higher the chance for burnout.”
To keep employees engaged but not overtaxed, LaBrosse
requires them to finish a project — or at least accomplish a
significant aspect — within three months. If someone is burning out,
she’ll switch them to another project. Another option is to rotate
people and jobs when possible. “An important factor is having the
right people for the work,” says Bradley Starr, chief people officer of
marketing firm MRM. “One person can be happy in another person’s
burnout role.”
Other ways to fight burnout:
- Suggest that the employee take a vacation
- Promote the employee, if it’s fitting
- Reward/recognize the employee
- Reduce the amount on the employee’s plate, if
reasonable - Ask the employee what would make their job more satisfying
and less stressful