GOP Insiders: Lott's Fate Still Unclear

Senate Republican Leader Trent Lott apologized Friday for reopening old racial wounds with remarks on segregation, and asked "forbearance and forgiveness" as he struggled to quell a controversy that threatened his hold on power.

Apologetic and defiant by turns, the Mississippi Republican rejected Democratic calls for resignation from his leadership post. "I'm not about to resign for an accusation for something I'm not," he said, adding that none of his Senate GOP colleagues had suggested he step down.

Within an hour of the news conference, several GOP senators issued statements of support for their embattled leader. Sen. Mitch McConnell of Kentucky, the incoming GOP whip, said, "I believe the American people will accept his apology and want us now to move forward together."

Several other Republican senators, including John Warner of Virginia and Peter Fitzgerald of Illinois, joined the "enough is enough" chorus.

But other lawmakers, outgoing GOP whip Don Nickles of Oklahoma among them, kept their own counsel. And several senior Republicans, speaking on condition of anonymity, said Lott's survival as leader was not a foregone conclusion.

Several GOP sources, also speaking on condition of anonymity, said Lott's office organized a conference call of Republican senators following his appearance in an attempt to shore up support. The sources added that while no participants suggested Lott step aside, concern was expressed about the long-term impact of the race-based controversy on the GOP legislative agenda, on President Bush and on the election prospects of Senate Republicans in 2004.

Several Republicans - Mr. Bush most prominent among them - have also sharply criticized Lott's statements. While the White House has not urged Lott to resign, GOP political aides have expressed fear about the effect of his remarks on efforts by Mr. Bush and others to expand the Republican share of the black vote.

And sources have told CBS News Chief Washington Correspondent Bob Schieffer that influential Republicans — some of them inside the White House — are now urging the president to work behind the scenes to get Lott to step down from his leadership post.

But CBS News correspondent John Roberts says some Republicans are worried that if the heat gets hot enough, Lott could quit the Senate altogether, in which case Mississippi's governor would appoint a Democrat to take his place, and the Senate would have a 50-50 split between Republicans and Democrats again.

Sen. Chuck Hagel, R-Neb., said Lott's apology was necessary. "He let his party down," Hagel said. He added, "I know of no one in our party calling for him to step down."

Rhode Island Sen. Lincoln Chafee, a moderate Republican, told The Providence Journal that Lott's remarks smacked of "stupidity." He did not call for Lott to step aside, saying he worries that potential successors might be even more conservative than the Mississippian.

Democrats have heaped criticism on Lott. One official, speaking on condition of anonymity, said Senate Democrats were considering whether to call for a formal censure vote of the GOP leader, a suggestion first made Thursday by the Congressional Black Caucus.

Liberal and civil rights groups have said the remarks were not an aberration, but emblematic of Lott's political career.

Thus far, some civil rights leaders and two Democratic senators - John Kerry of Massachusetts and Russ Feingold of Wisconsin - have called on Lott to step aside as leader. But the Mississippian serves at the will of fellow Republican senators. Whatever their discomfort, none of them has yet publicly called for his ouster.

In one bright spot for Lott, Sen. James Jeffords of Vermont, who abandoned the Republican Party to become an independent last year partly because of differences with the conservative Lott, issued a statement calling Lott "a man of honor and good conscience."

A senior White House official said Lott's apology was important - and different from previous attempts to lay the controversy to rest - because it would be his first on camera. Senior White House aides privately prodded Lott to make a public mea culpa; Sen. John McCain, R-Ariz., publicly urged him to do so.

"Let me be clear: Segregation and racism are immoral," Lott said at the Friday news conference, at a hotel in Pascagoula, Miss. He added, "I lived through the troubled times in the South, and along with the South, I have learned from the mistakes of our past."

The GOP leader also spoke approvingly of remarks that Mr. Bush made on the subject Thursday. "Recent comments by Sen. Lott do not reflect the spirit of our country," Mr. Bush said at the time.

Lott, 61 and in line to become Senate majority leader in January, triggered an uproar last week when he said that Mississippians were proud to have voted for Sen. Strom Thurmond in 1948 on the pro-segregationist Dixiecrat ticket. "And if the rest of the country had followed our lead, we wouldn't have had all these problems over all these years either," Lott added in remarks at Thurmond's 100th birthday.

At the news conference Friday, Lott said he had been "winging it" with his utterances at Thurmond's party, saying they were not meant to convey support for racial segregation. Rather, he said, they marked an effort to help "an elderly gentleman to feel good. There were no venal thoughts in my mind."

"Segregation is a stain on our nation's soul. There is no other way to describe it," Lott said. He said Thurmond, over his long career, came to renounce "repugnant views" on race. "That said, I apologize for reopening old wounds and hurting so many Americans."

Lott also said he was hoping to reach agreement with Robert Johnson, the head of Black Entertainment Television, to make an hourlong appearance next week to discuss opportunities for all Americans.

Lott had sought earlier to end the controversy with more modest measures, including a written apology and telephone interviews. He stepped before microphones eight days after uttering the comments that threw his own political future into doubt.

At the Friday news conference, Lott made multiple denunciations of the system of segregation that was prevalent when he was a young man in his native South. "I have asked and am asking for people's forbearance and forgiveness as I continue to learn from my own mistakes and as I continue to grow as both a person and a leader," he said.

While Republicans have squirmed since the controversy erupted, Democrats did what they could to raise questions about Lott's views on civil rights in an attempt to maximize the political pain for him and his party.

With Lott speaking favorably of the Dixiecrat campaign of 1948, for example, Democrats turned up a document marked as a sample ballot distributed to Mississippi voters that year, when Thurmond ran as a segregationist alternative to Democratic President Harry Truman.

A vote for Truman's presidential electors, the sample ballot said, amounts to a vote for "passage of Truman's so-called civil rights program in the next Congress." That means, it added, that "anti-lynching and anti-segregation proposals will become the law of the land and our way of life in the South will be gone forever."

Lott began his day on vacation in Key West, Fla. - a location that Truman chose for his vacations while serving as president.