Mandatory Vaccine Bill Passes 1st Hurdle In Sacramento Despite Passionate Protests
SACRAMENTO (CBS SF) - The fierce debate over whether the state should have the power to force parents to vaccinate their children will continue to rage in California after a bill mandating vaccinations cleared a first hurdle Wednesday.
The measure passed out of the Senate Health Committee on a 6-2 vote Wednesday evening after impassioned testimony from supporters and opponents. Under the proposal, parents would no longer be able to send unvaccinated kids to school with waivers citing religious or personal beliefs. Exemptions would be available only for children with health problems.
The measure, SB277 from Sen. Richard Pan, was in the earliest stages of the legislative process but drew large crowds, including parents who brought their children. During the emotionally charged hearing, one opponent threatened to put a curse on lawmakers who voted for the bill and another woman was removed after an outburst.
Supporters say the measure would increase the number of vaccinated young people and improve public health.
Opponents say vaccines can be as dangerous as the diseases they aim to fight and that the bill would trample parental rights. The group "Your Kids Your Choice" joined Robert Kennedy Jr. for a rally at the Capitol Wednesday.
Kennedy said at a Sacramento rally ahead of Wednesday's Senate Health Committee hearing that the pharmaceutical industry profits immensely when governments make vaccines mandatory. He reportedly compared the use of some vaccines to "a holocaust."
"The checks and balances in our democratic system that are supposed stand between corporate power and our little children have been removed," Kennedy said. "And there's only one barrier left and that's the parents."
On Wednesday, Kennedy's comments were more subdued.
"I'm pro vaccine," he said. "I think vaccinations save millions of lives...we ought to have policies that encourage full vaccination...but that's not going to happen until we have safe vaccines."
Other members of the "Your Kids Your Choice" group were vocal in their opposition.
"My 4-year-old son is vax-free and very healthy and I would leave the country before I would vaccinate him because of the dangers," said Brandy Vaughn, a former pharmaceutical sale rep from San Francisco.
Opponents say vaccines can be as dangerous as the diseases they aim to fight and that the bill would trample parental rights.
Karen Kain said her daughter died of injuries from a mercury-tainted vaccine. "I stand here today before you to share my story so you can all see and hear what happens when vaccines go wrong," she said. "Who gets to make the choice now of whose babies are more important? Because there is risk, there must be choice."
Similar efforts to reduce exemptions were proposed elsewhere after a measles outbreak in December that started at Disneyland and sickened more than 100 people across the U.S. and in Mexico. In Oregon and Washington state, however, such proposals were rejected recently.
Ariel Loop told lawmakers inside the Capitol that the bill could have prevented her child from contracting measles at Disneyland. "My infant shouldn't have had to suffer. He shouldn't, still months later, be having complications with his eyes," she said. "I shouldn't have had to fear for his life."
Dr. Dean Blumberg, a pediatrician who testified on behalf of the American Academy of Pediatrics and the California Medical Association, said childhood vaccination has been so successful that it's easy to overstate their risks and dismiss the diseases they prevent.
"Unfortunately, there's much misinformation about vaccine safety and effectiveness," Blumberg said. "Let me be clear: There is no scientific controversy about vaccine safety and vaccine effectiveness. ... This is not open to dispute among mainstream doctors and scientists."
According to the National Conference of State Legislatures, California is among 20 states that allow for personal belief exemptions and 48 that allow for religious exemptions.
Public health officials believe an immunization rate of at least 90 percent is critical to minimizing the potential for a disease outbreak. California's kindergarteners met that threshold at the start of this school year, according to state statistics: 2 percent were exempted because of their parents' personal beliefs and another half a percent were exempted because of their parents' religion.
If the bill passes, California would join Mississippi and West Virginia as the only states with such strict vaccine rules.
TM and © Copyright 2015 CBS Radio Inc. and its relevant subsidiaries. CBS RADIO and EYE Logo TM and Copyright 2015 CBS Broadcasting Inc. Used under license. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten. The Associated Press contributed to this report.