"America's Most Wanted" suspect in woman's 1984 killing returned to Florida after living for years as water board president in California
A man arrested earlier this month in California has been returned to Florida to face charges in the 1984 killing of a woman, authorities said. Officials say Donald Santini, 65, had been serving as the president of a local water board in a San Diego suburb when he was finally apprehended.
Santini was booked into a Florida jail Wednesday morning on a charge of first-degree murder, according to a Hillsborough County Sheriff's Office statement. Florida detectives had traveled to San Diego, California, following Santini's June 7 arrest, and he was later extradited to Tampa, Florida.
"The arrest of Donald Santini brings closure to a long-standing cold case and provides justice for the victim and her family after nearly four decades of waiting," Hillsborough County Sheriff Chad Chronister said in a statement. "Let's not forget the tireless work that has gone into this case over the years, the resources, and expertise to pursue justice for Cynthia Wood."
Santini had been on the run since June 1984, when Florida authorities obtained an arrest warrant linking him to the strangling death of Wood, a 33-year-old Bradenton woman.
Wood's body was found in a drainage ditch about five days after she went missing on June 6 of that year, according to the sheriff's office.
Santini was the last person seen with Wood. The arrest warrant said a medical examiner determined she had been strangled and Santini's fingerprints were found on her body, WFTS-TV reported. Authorities previously said Santini may have been living in Texas using an unknown identity.
Santini appeared several times on the television show "America's Most Wanted" in 1990, 2005 and 2013. Over the years, officials said Florida detectives sent lead requests to Texas, California and even as far as Thailand, but Santini was never located. He used at least 13 aliases while on the run, according to an arrest warrant from the Hillsborough Sheriff's Office cited by USA Today.
Santini was arrested while living for years under the name of Wellman Simmonds in San Diego County, where he was president of a local water board in Campo, a tiny suburb of San Diego. He regularly appeared at public board meetings.
Donald Michael SANTINI was arrested by Deputies of the San Diego Fugitive Task Force in Campo, CA. SANTINI was wanted in Hillsborough County, FL for the murder of Cynthia Ruth Wood in 1984. SANTINI was featured multiple times on America's Most Wanted #fugitive #USMarshals pic.twitter.com/p4kXeLJvAW
— USMS San Diego (@USMSSanDiego) June 12, 2023
"The reason I have been able to run so long is to live a loving respectful life," Santini told ABC 10News in a handwritten 16-page letter sent from jail, the San Diego station reported earlier this week.
Santini wrote that he volunteered with the Rotary Club, owned a Thai restaurant and ran an apartment block, the TV station reported.
Santini previously served time in prison for raping a woman while stationed in Germany, officials said. He was also wanted in Texas for aggravated robbery.
A tip from the Florida/Caribbean Regional Fugitive Task Force led U.S. Marshals to Campo, in San Diego County, where they arrested Santini, KGTV reported.
Santini was being represented by the public defender's office, which didn't immediately respond to an after-hours telephone message seeking comment.
He told ABC10 News that his public defender told him to be quiet in court at his extradition hearing.
"Things are not as they seem," he wrote to the station. "I need a lawyer that doesn't try to push me through the system to keep me quiet. The problem is I have no money."