COVID Update: BART Board Approves Incentivized Retirement Program To Address Budget Woes
OAKLAND (CBS SF) -- The BART Board of Directors voted Thursday to forge ahead with an incentivized retirement program intended to help mend the agency's ailing financial outlook due to the coronavirus pandemic.
By an 8-1 vote, the board elected to offer up to 24 weeks of base pay to full-time employees who are or will be eligible for retirement by March 21, 2021.
By that date, some 1,650 employees will meet the criteria for retirement eligibility, which include being at least 50 years old and being a BART employee for at least five years, according to agency officials.
Employees who take advantage of the incentivized retirement offer would receive four weeks of base pay plus one week of pay per full year they've worked for BART, capped at 20 years.
Eligible employees will have four weeks from Nov. 23 to Dec. 18 to express interest in the program, as well as a 45-day window to submit a signed retirement agreement with the agency.
BART officials have determined that roughly 300 employees are most likely to retire at a total cost of $15 million to the agency.
"I think that there are tools that we have in our tool belt," Board Director Mark Foley said. "Let's use them now and do what we can to get through this fiscal year."
While that payout would be a net cost of $5 million more than BART has allocated for salary and benefits in the current budget, it would ultimately save the agency roughly $45 million in salary and benefits during fiscal year 2022, which would start July 1, 2021.
Agency officials argued incentivizing retirement for the agency's longest-tenured employees would help BART avoid future layoffs as ridership remains depleted due to the pandemic, gutting the agency's gate fare revenue.
"It will still be a savings. It won't cost more than it will save. The idea here is to avoid layoffs. We don't want to layoff our employees, so lets first see who wants to voluntarily retire," said BART spokeswoman Alicia Trost.
A representative for the union that represents BART maintenance, utility and clerical workers said avoiding layoffs is a huge relief to members.
"The package is not a 'Wow!' package. It is a decent package, all depending on how long you've been here. The longer you've been here, the better it gets," said SEIU 1021 President John Arantes.
BART budget officials have meticulously tried to avoid layoffs, putting off staff expansions and using federal funding to make up for the lost ridership revenue.
Back in May, early on in the pandemic, BART's projected fiscal year 2020-2021 budget included more than $100 million in cuts. Last month, BART officials said the agency was on track to face a $33 million budget deficit by next summer if the system did not see an increase in passengers or more federal relief funding.
Board Director Debora Allen, the lone vote against the incentivized retirement program, argued that a more targeted strategy would prevent the retirement program from blowing holes in the staffs of BART's various departments.
Allen also said the savings generated by the program would only come to fruition if the retired positions remained unfilled, a suggestion the agency's budget officials agreed with.
"There's got to be a better way to do this," she said. "This approach puts us in a position to have a lot of people moving around and a lot more uncertainty than we need right now."
Should the pandemic continue deep into 2021 and keep ridership at a fraction of BART's normal levels, BART budget director Christopher Simi said the agency's budget staff has prepared scenarios in which deep cuts to service may be necessary, a possibility multiple board directors balked at.
In addition to the retirement incentive, BART service will remain at pandemic levels possibly through to September, meaning trains will not run past nine p.m.
One BART rider said the limited service was not an optimal solution for some.
"I mean, for people who work at night, that's really bad. How are people going to get down here?" asked rider Mark Shoffner
BART socked away Cares Act funding and won't run out until the early fall of next year.
"All of this could be a moot point if we got federal emergency aid," said Trost. :We continue to advocate for that. We don't know that it's coming. We can't assume that it's coming. We don't know the timeline."
"We will not be able to cut our way out of our deficit," Board Director Janice Li said, "even in the most aggressive scenario of layoffs."
According to Pamela Herhold, BART's assistant general manager for performance and budget, the agency brought in more revenue than expected during the first quarter of fiscal year 2021, allowing BART to put $12 million in its reserves with a projected $33 million budget deficit looming at the end of the fiscal year.
"I'm not going to count on that every single quarter, but certainly right now, with what we can control, we're headed in the right direction," said Herhold.
Andria Borba contributed to this story.
© Copyright 2020 CBS Broadcasting Inc. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. Bay City News Service contributed to this report.