Lurie leads Breed, fights off others challengers in San Francisco mayoral race
The race for San Francisco mayor has come down to a final vote count between incumbent London Breed and political newcomer Daniel Lurie.
As of 6 a.m. Wednesday, Lurie had eclipsed all other challengers and was leading Breed 28% to 24.6% in first-place votes in the ranked-choice race. Board of Supervisors president Aaron Peskin was in third place with 21.5% and former interim Mayor Mark Farrell was fourth at 18.4% with less than 50% of precincts counted.
These early results included mail-in ballots and about 37,300 ballots cast at voting centers.
But these numbers do not reflect who wins in the end since San Francisco uses a ranked-choice voting system to decide the winner. Of the ballots counted so far, multiple rounds of eliminating candidates and redistributing their votes to the remaining candidates showed Lurie receiving many transferred votes.
After all of the candidates are eliminated except for Breed and Lurie, Breed ended up with about 44% and Lurie with 56%, according to the initial results Tuesday night.
When Farrell was eliminated, over half of his votes transferred over to Lurie.
"Lurie's getting about 55% of vote transfers from Mark Farrell, which is a big deal. And, that's one of the key reasons why he's winning in the end," Jason McDaniel, a political science professor at San Francisco State University, said in an interview.
Six years ago, incumbent Breed became the first Black woman to serve as mayor of San Francisco in a special election to fill the position after the death of Mayor Ed Lee in late 2017.
She has faced a number of major challenges during her first term in office, including the COVID-19 pandemic, the city's ongoing issues with drug abuse and homelessness, rising housing costs and a spike in retail crime that some chains cited as the reason behind closing stores in San Francisco.
While Breed has touted progress in reducing the number of homeless encampments and pushed programs to fill vacant business spaces downtown, the mayor's struggles have led to 11 other candidates entering the race to challenge her for the job.
At his election night party Tuesday, Farrell conceded the race as results came in. He said will get behind whoever is the next mayor.
His support appeared to wane leading up to Election Day due to three former mayors calling for an investigation into his campaign finance tactics. The San Francisco Ethics Commission then handed him a large fine right before Election Day for using some money from his Proposition D campaign to fund his separate campaign for mayor.
"There just was not a lot of positive stories driving Farrell's campaign in the last several months in the election," McDaniel said.
He formed an alliance with fellow candidate Ahsha Safai as a strategy around ranked-choice voting to share each other's voting blocks. However, it appears unfruitful because Safai received only 3% of votes.
"His votes didn't transfer that much support to Farrell. That might change a little bit as more votes get counted but it's not enough to make a difference," McDaniel said.
Lurie is the only top candidate from outside San Francisco politics, never holding a position in local government.
"We knew this would not be easy," Lurie said in a speech at his election party Tuesday night. "The last time someone from outside of city government became the mayor of San Francisco was 1911. It was five years after the earthquake and it was an inflection point. And here we are, more than a century later and our city finds itself at another inflection point."
"Election Day voters tend to be more progressive, more left-leaning and younger," McDaniel said. "These are the kind of voters that will vote in higher numbers for Aaron Peskin probably and I expect London Breed as well. If that doesn't happen, then I think this will be a Lurie victory. But I expect the next block of voters to not look as good for Lurie as this block of voters did."
Results will continue to update in the coming days as more ballots get counted.
One of the main downsides to ranked-choice voting is that voters may have to patiently wait until a final result is determined. The city has one month to finalize the count.
"We haven't had any major electoral complications around ranked-choice voting, except waiting for it to be tallied," James Taylor, a political science expert and professor at the University of San Francisco, said in an interview. "The waiting part is about the only confusion that happens with ranked-choice voting."
When Breed won the mayoral race in 2018, it took eight rounds for her to secure a majority of first-choice votes. She took the lead in the first round, receiving 37% of first-pick votes, according to the Department of Elections.
Bay City News contributed to this report.