Economy likely to resume steady growth, but some money will never be made up
The U.S. economy will likely resume its steady growth now that the government has reopened, though economists say some scars — for the nation and for federal workers — will take time to heal.
Most analysts estimate that the 35-day partial shutdown shaved a few tenths of a percentage point from annual economic growth in the first three month of 2019. They say growth should pick up in the coming months, though some of the money federal workers and contractors didn't spend in the past five weeks — on such items as movie tickets, restaurants and travel — will never be made up.
Having gone without two paychecks, many federal workers were forced to visit food banks or to borrow money.
Federal workers will be compensated when the government reopens. But workers in the roughly 4 million private-sector jobs that depend on the federal government won't receive back pay.
S&P Global Ratings estimates that the economy lost $6 billion because of the government closure — a sizable but relatively negligible sum in a $19 trillion-plus U.S. economy.
"If the shutdown had lasted much longer, the economic impacts would have snowballed — travel problems, tax refunds, etc.," said Stephen Stanley, chief economist at Amherst Pierpont Securities.
Still, the damage isn't likely to lift immediately. And some federal employees had expressed anxiety during the shutdown about the stability and security of their jobs. The most skilled or talented among them may be likelier to leave government service, a potential problem for an economy already facing worker shortages in some areas.
Job searches by employees at multiple federal agencies jumped during the shutdown, according to clicks tracked by the jobs site Indeed. Employees who had gone unpaid at the Department of Homeland Security, Census Bureau, the IRS and the Transportation Safety Administration were much more likely to be hunting for a new job compared with the past two years of searches.
During the shutdown, a shortage of airport security and air traffic controllers disrupted travel at such major hubs as LaGuardia Airport in New York and Newark Liberty International Airport in New Jersey. The pressure on Mr. Trump to reopen the government intensified Friday after a delay of about 3,000 flights by mid-afternoon because six of 13 air traffic controllers didn't show up to work at a critical center in Virginia.
The FBI Agents Association warned this week that the shutdown was not only hurting individual FBI employees and their families, but hampering key operations. Some of those affected operations, according to a series of statements the association released Tuesday, included efforts to thwart the same criminal enterprises Mr. Trump claims the shutdown was meant to defeat in the long run.
President Trump agreed to reopen the government for three weeks on Friday after having forced the shutdown in hopes of compelling Democrats to approve billions for a wall on the Mexico border. One lingering risk now is if Mr. Trump chooses to shutter the government again after the agreement lapses on February 15. Should that occur, it would sabotage consumer confidence and hurt the economy, predicted Mark Zandi, chief economist at Moody's Analytics.
"It would wipe out confidence," Zandi said.
However, six Republican senators voted for the failed bill to refund the government without wall money on Thursday, showing discontent in the GOP ranks. Mr. Trump has threatened to declare a national emergency if Congress does not agree to provide funding for the wall.